The Woman of Knockaloe: A Parable — Themes and Context

(0 User reviews)   39
Caine, Hall, Sir, 1853-1931 Project Gutenberg 2021 Not confirmed
World War, 1914-1918 -- Fiction; Isle of Man -- Fiction Readers of public-domain and historical texts
Project Gutenberg digital edition en

Edition facts

Words 36,734
Reading time 160 min
Text sections 4

Before opening The Woman of Knockaloe: A Parable — Themes and Context, the edition data offers a quick orientation: 36,734 words, 2 hr 40 min estimated reading time, and 4 detected text sections.

The text analysis averages about 16.4 words per sentence, while the detected sections provide another way to judge how the source is divided.

Project Gutenberg metadata also associates the work with “World War, 1914-1918 -- Fiction,” connecting these edition facts with the source record’s subject description.

An editorial note on Hall Caine's 1923 novel set in an Isle of Man internment camp during WWI, focusing on how the excerpts reveal the story's structure, the role of the hymn 'Ein feste Burg', and the restrained depiction of war's end.
Share
Editorial Edition Score 4.6/5

Calculated from edition completeness, EPUB availability, text structure and catalogue metadata. Not a user rating.

How this score is calculated
  • Description quality20 pts
  • Title & short description10 pts
  • Source metadata20 pts
  • Text length15 pts
  • Chapters / structure15 pts
  • EPUB file integrity20 pts

Total of 100 points, scaled to a 2.5-5.0 range. Editions with an empty description or a missing EPUB file are not scored.

Edition quality

Read the Text

uld not put aside an urgent task and write out my dream into a story, and other reasons why I should not attempt to publish anything that was so much opposed to the temper of the time, but I had to write it for the relief of my own feelings, and here it is written. And now I publish it with many misgivings and only one expectation--that in the present troubled condition of the world, in the midst of the jealousy and hatred, the suffering and misery of the nations, which leave them groaning and travailing in pain, and heading on to an apparently inevitable catastrophe, even so humble and so slight a thing as this may perhaps help the march of a moving Providence and the healing of the Almighty hand.

“It was a dream. Ah, what is not a dream?”

Knockaloe[1] is a large farm on the west of the Isle of Man, a little to the south of the fishing town of Peel. From the farmstead I can see the harbour and the breakwater, with the fishing boats moored within and the broad curve of the sea outside.

There is a ridge of hills that separates the farm from the coast, which is rocky and precipitous. On the crest of the hills there is a square tower that is commonly called “Corrin’s Folly,” and at the foot of the tower there is a small graveyard surrounded by a stone wall.

Too far inland to hear the roar of the sea except in winter, it is near enough to feel its salt breath in the summer. Not rich or leafy or luxuriant, but with a broad sunny bareness as of a place where a glacier has been and passed over, and with a deep peace, a glacial peace, always lying on it--such is Knockaloe.

The farm-house lies in the valley, close under the shelter of the hills. It is a substantial building with large outhouses, and it is approached from the road by a long, straight, narrow lane that is bordered by short trees.

The farmer is Robert Craine, a stalwart old man in a sleeve waistcoat. I seem to know him well. He has farmed Knockaloe all his life, following three or four generations of his family. But now he is a little past his best, and rarely goes far from home except on Sundays to one or other of the chapels round about, for he is a local preacher among the Wesleyans.

“I’m not too good at the farming now,” he says, “but, man, I love to preach.”

His wife is dead, and she is buried in the churchyard of Kirk Patrick, which lies near his gate at the turn of the road to the railway station. He has a son and a daughter. The son, another Robert, but commonly called Robbie, is a fine young fellow with clear flashing eyes, about six and twenty, as fresh as the heather on the mountains, and his father’s right-hand man. The daughter is named Mona, and she is a splendid girl of about twenty-three or four, distinctly good-looking, tall, full-bosomed, strong of limb, even muscular, with firm step and upright figure, big brown eyes and coal-black hair--a picture of grown-up health. Since her mother’s death she has become “the big woman” of the farm, managing everything and everybody, the farm-servants of both sexes, her brother and even her father.

Mona has no sweetheart, but she has many suitors. The most persistent is heir to the cold and “boney” farm which makes boundary with Knockaloe. They call him “long John Corlett,” and his love-making is as crude as his figure.

“Wouldn’t it be grand if we only had enough cattle between us to run milk into Douglas?”

Mona reads him like a book and sends him about his business.

Knockaloe has a few fields under cultivation (I see some acres of oats and wheat), but it is chiefly a grazing farm, supplying most of the milk for the people of Peel. At six in the morning the maids milk the cows, and at seven Mona drives the milk into town in a shandry that is full of tall milk-cans.

It is Sunday morning in the early part of August, nineteen hundred and fourteen. The sun has risen bright and clear, giving promise of another good day. Mona is driving out of the gate when she hears the crack of a rocket from the rocket-house connected with the lifeboat. She looks towards the sea. It lies as calm as a sleeping child, and there is not a ship in sight anywhere. What does it mean?

The excerpts from The Woman of Knockaloe: A Parable open with an editorial note that frames the work as both a love story and a parable against war. The narrative then plunges into a camp scene where a pastor reads from a big Bible to five or six hundred prisoners. The entrance of Mona, known as “the Woman of Knockaloe,” is marked by a sudden hush and a chair hurriedly brought in. The prisoners sing Luther’s hymn Ein feste Burg in German, and Mona joins in English, creating a moment of unity. This early passage establishes the camp as a confined world and Mona as a figure who bridges two communities.

A Confined World Introduced

The opening excerpt immediately establishes the camp’s physical and emotional boundaries: “a mile and a half by half a mile of land” enclosed by barbed wire, holding twenty-five thousand men and one woman. The description of the prisoners—some in rags, some with “naked feet showing through the holes in their worn-out shoes”—grounds the story in specific, tangible details. The pastor’s lesson and the hymn create a ritualistic atmosphere. Mona’s entrance is theatrical: she stands “as if dazed by the eyes that are on her,” and a man touches her arm to lead her to a chair. This moment signals her central role without yet revealing her history.

The Hymn as a Bridge

The hymn Ein feste Burg ist unser Gott recurs as a structural device. In the opening, Mona sings the English version while the prisoners sing in German, and their voices “rise and swell until the place seemed to throb with them.” Later, when the war’s end approaches, the same hymn is mentioned again. The shared melody becomes a quiet symbol of common humanity. The excerpts do not explain why Mona knows the hymn or what it means to her, but its repetition suggests it is a touchstone. Readers should note how the hymn reappears and what emotional weight it carries each time.

Shifting Moods Inside the Camp

The middle excerpt captures the prisoners’ changing spirits as the war progresses. They move from “truculent” boasts about German forces marching on London to “sceptical” dismissal of English news, then to “sullen” indifference: “What is the war about, anyway? Nothing at all!” This progression is rendered in short, declarative sentences. Mona’s own state is described as “a fever of excitement.” The passage ends with Oskar’s late-night visit, where he calls her “Mona” for the first time. His news of Germany’s defeat is met with her hesitant question: “But surely you are glad of that, Oskar?” His reply—“I don’t know. I can’t say”—introduces ambiguity about his feelings.

The War’s End, Unresolved

The final excerpt, dated “The tenth of November, nineteen hundred and eighteen,” is cut short by the Project Gutenberg boilerplate. What remains is Oskar’s announcement that “Germany is beaten” and the Hindenburg line is broken. Mona’s heart throbs, but Oskar’s response is evasive. The narrative stops before showing the armistice or its aftermath. This abrupt truncation leaves the reader with a sense of incompleteness. The editorial note earlier promised a “tremendous end,” but the excerpts do not deliver it. A first-time reader should be aware that the story’s resolution is not captured in these samples.

The excerpts from The Woman of Knockaloe offer a concentrated view of the camp’s atmosphere and the central relationship between Mona and Oskar. The hymn, the confined setting, and the shifting moods of the prisoners are all established with economy. Readers approaching the full text should watch for how these elements develop, particularly the symbolic use of the hymn and the resolution of Oskar’s internal conflict. The story’s subtitle, “A Parable,” hints at a moral dimension that the excerpts only begin to suggest.

Reading about the hymn in Knockaloe reminded me of my grandmother humming old tunes during quiet afternoons. I once held that same stillness with The Arizona Callahan — Context and Discussion, where a single desert night felt as vast and patient as an internment camp’s waiting, both books leaving me with the ache of space between people.

There are no reviews for this eBook.

0
0 out of 5 (0 User reviews )

Add a Review

Your Rating *
  • ...
    Donald Clay - 3 weeks ago
    The Woman of Knockaloe is a beautifully written parable with a strong emotional core. The historical setting and the central relationship are compelling. That said, the allegorical elements sometimes feel heavy-handed, and the pacing is uneven. Still, it's a thoughtful and evocative read for fans of literary fiction.

  • ...
    Patricia Brian Hernandez - 3 weeks ago
    A deeply moving parable that explores themes of love, sacrifice, and redemption during the Great War. The author's prose is lyrical and haunting, painting a vivid picture of life on the Isle of Man. The characters are authentic, and the moral complexity keeps you engaged until the final page. A profound read.

  • ...
    Crystal Hansen - 2 weeks ago
    Despite its promising premise, this book falls short. The narrative is dense and slow, and the characters lack depth, making it hard to connect with their struggles. The parable's message feels forced rather than organic. While the historical setting is well-researched, the execution fails to deliver an engaging or enlightening experience.


Reader reflection

Record your reading impressions

A brief reflection can help important ideas stay with you longer.

Your progress 0 / 10
1

Where are you in your reading?

2

Was reading this book enjoyable?

3

Would you encourage someone else to read it?

4

What was the reading difficulty like?

Related eBooks